Skip to main content

Table 4 Contamination indices and ranking of tailings impoundments located in the Aries river basin a

From: Characterization and assessment of potential environmental risk of tailings stored in seven impoundments in the Aries river basin, Western Romania

Enrichment factor (Ef)

Impoundment

No (0 < Ef ≤ 1)

Minor (1 < Ef ≤ 3)

Moderate (3 < Ef ≤ 5)

Moderately severe (5 < Ef ≤ 10)

Severe (10 < Ef ≤ 25)

Very severe (25 < Ef ≤ 50)

Extremely severe (Ef > 50)

Saliste

Ni < Cr

Cu

-

Zn(9.8)

Pb(22), Cd(23)

-

As(251)

Gura Rosiei

Cr < Ni

Cu

Zn

Cd(7.7)

-

Pb(43)

As(255)

Stefanca

Cr < Ni

-

Pb < Zn

Cd(5.4), As(9.6)

-

-

Cu(61)

Sesei

Ni < Cr

-

Pb < Zn

Cd(9.1)

As(11)

-

Cu(76)

Cutii

Ni < Cr

-

-

Zn(6.4), Cd(9.1), Cu(9.5)

-

-

Pb(59), As(715)

Sartas

Cr

Ni

-

-

Cu(12), Zn(13)

-

Cd(34), Pb(73), As(860)

Brazesti

Cr < Ni

-

-

Cu(6.9)

Zn(12)

Cd(41)

Pb(70), As(1100)

Geoaccumulation index (I geo )

Impoundment

Practically unpolluted (I geo  < 0)

Unpolluted to moderately polluted (0 < I geo  ≤ 1)

Moderately polluted (1 < I geo  ≤ 2)

Moderately to heavily polluted (2 < I geo  ≤ 3)

Heavily polluted (3 < I geo  ≤ 4)

Heavily to extremely polluted (4 < I geo  ≤ 5)

Extremely polluted (I geo  > 5)

Saliste

Cr < Ni < Cu

Zn

Pb(2.0), Cd(2.0)

-

-

-

As(5.5)

Gura Rosiei

Cr < Ni < Cu < Zn < Cd

-

Pb(1.9)

-

-

As(4.5)

-

Stefanca

Cr < Ni < Pb

Zn < Cd

As(1.3)

-

Cu(3.9)

-

-

Sesei

Ni < Cr

Zn < Pb

Cd(1.5), As(1.7)

-

-

Cu(4.5)

-

Cutii

Ni < Cr

Zn

Cd(1.4), Cu(1.5)

-

-

Pb(4.1)

As(7.8)

Sartas

Cr < Ni

 

Cu(1.8), Zn(1.9)

-

Cd(3.4)

Pb(4.4)

As(8.0)

Brazesti

Cr < Ni

Cu

Zn(1.6)

-

Cd(3.4)

Pb(4.2)

As(8.2)

Contamination factor (C f )

Impoundment

Low (C f <1)

Moderate (1 < C f ≤3)

Considerable (3 < C f  ≤ 6)

Very high (C f >6)

Saliste

Ni < Cr < Cu

Zn(2.6)

Pb(5.9)

Cd(6.1), As(67)

Gura Rosiei

Cr < Ni < Cu < Zn < Cd

-

Pb(5.8)

As(34)

Stefanca

Cr < Ni

Pb(1.3), Zn(1.4), Cd(2.0)

As(3.7)

Cu(23)

Sesei

Ni < Cr

Zn(1.5), Pb(1.6)

Cd(4.1), As(4.9)

Cu(34)

Cutii

Ni < Cr

Zn(2.9)

Cd(4.1), Cu(4.3)

Pb(26), As(321)

Sartas

Cr < Ni

-

Cu(5.3), Zn(5.6)

Cd(15), Pb(32), As(384)

Brazesti

Cr < Ni

Cu(2.6)

Zn(4.6)

Cd(16), Pb(28), As(437)

Contamination degree (C d )

 

Low (C d <8)

Moderate (8 < C d  ≤ 16)

Considerable (16 < C d  ≤ 32)

Very high (C d >32)

Impoundment

-

-

-

 

Stefanca (32), Gura Rosiei, (42), Sesei (46), Saliste (83), Cutii (360), Sartas (443), Brazesti (488)

  1. a based on seven typical metals for the studied area.