- Research article
- Open Access
Cacao seeds are a "Super Fruit": A comparative analysis of various fruit powders and products
Chemistry Central Journalvolume 5, Article number: 5 (2011)
Numerous popular media sources have developed lists of "Super Foods" and, more recently, "Super Fruits". Such distinctions often are based on the antioxidant capacity and content of naturally occurring compounds such as polyphenols within those whole fruits or juices of the fruit which may be linked to potential health benefits. Cocoa powder and chocolate are made from an extract of the seeds of the fruit of the Theobroma cacao tree. In this study, we compared cocoa powder and cocoa products to powders and juices derived from fruits commonly considered "Super Fruits".
Various fruit powders and retail fruit products were obtained and analyzed for antioxidant capacity (ORAC (μM TE/g)), total polyphenol content (TP (mg/g)), and total flavanol content (TF (mg/g)). Among the various powders that were tested, cocoa powder was the most concentrated source of ORAC and TF. Similarly, dark chocolate was a significantly more concentrated source of ORAC and TF than the fruit juices.
Cocoa powder and dark chocolate had equivalent or significantly greater ORAC, TP, and TF values compared to the other fruit powders and juices tested, respectively. Cacao seeds thus provide nutritive value beyond that derived from their macronutrient composition and appear to meet the popular media's definition of a "Super Fruit".
Many popular press articles have deemed certain foods as "Super Foods" due to a high purported nutritive value. This trend has crossed over into numerous fruits, fruit juices, and other fruit products wherein the high nutritive value is often based on the antioxidant capacity of these foods. Such fruits are commonly referred to as "Super Fruits" in popular media .
Cacao (or cocoa) beans are technically not beans or legumes, but rather the seeds of the fruit of the Theobroma cacao tree. The pod shaped fruit is botanically classified as baccate-like (berry-like) and each pod produces approximately 35-50 seeds surrounded by a sweet pulp . The pod and the pulp surrounding the cacao seed in this case constitute the fruit of cacao. After harvest, cacao seeds and their surrounding fruit pulp are typically placed in heaps or boxes and fermented under the influence of naturally occurring microbes that multiply using the sugar from the pulp as an energy source. The seeds are then dried in the sun or in wood fired ovens and shipped to cacao processors. Cacao seeds next have their thin coats removed from the embryonic tissue, which is then roasted, and milled into what is referred to as chocolate liquor. Cocoa powder is produced by mechanically pressing most of the fat (cocoa butter) from the chocolate liquor and thus represents an extract of the cacao fruit's seeds.
Cocoa powder and dark chocolate contain relatively high concentrations of certain polyphenolic compounds, most notably flavanols. Flavanols, especially the monomer epicatechin and oligomers and polymers of flavanols called proanthocyanins, can act as strong antioxidants in food systems . Notably, cocoa flavanols have been associated with numerous health benefits including the stimulation of nitric oxide synthase, improving blood flow and arterial elasticity, decreasing blood pressure and platelet aggregation, and having anti-inflammatory actions [4–6].
Generally, a fruit is thought of as the edible portion of a plant that surrounds its seeds. The fruit pulp of the Theobroma cacao pod that surrounds its seeds can be consumed; however the vast majority of people have only consumed the seed-derived portion of cacao in the form of cocoa powder or chocolate. For this reason, in the current study we compared cocoa powder and chocolate, products representing the commonly eaten portion of the cacao fruit, with powders and juices from so-called "Super Fruits" on measures of antioxidant activity, as measured by oxygen radical absorbance capacity (ORAC), total polyphenol content (TP), and total flavanol content (TF).
Results and Discussion
Analysis of the fruit powders demonstrated that the antioxidant capacity (Figure 1A) of cocoa powder (634 ± 33 μMTE/g) was significantly greater than blueberry, cranberry, and pomegranate powder on a per gram basis. The total polyphenol content (Figure 1B) of cocoa powder (48.2 ± 2.1 mg/g) appeared to be greater than acai, blueberry, and cranberry powder; however these differences did not reach statistical significance. The total flavanol content (Figure 1C) of cocoa powder (30.1 ± 2.8 mg/g) was significantly greater than all of the other fruit powders tested. There were no other statistically significant differences in antioxidant capacity, total polyphenol, or total flavanol content between any of the other fruit powders tested.
Analysis of fruit products demonstrated that the antioxidant capacity (Figure 2A) of dark chocolate (9911 ± 1079 μMTE/serving) was not significantly greater, on a per serving basis, than pomegranate juice but was greater than that of all other products tested. In contrast, hot cocoa mix had significantly less antioxidant capacity (1232 ± 159 μMTE/serving) than all of the other products tested. The total polyphenol content (Figure 2B) of dark chocolate (991.1 mg/serving) was significantly greater than all of the other products tested, aside from pomegranate juice, on a per serving basis. The total polyphenol content of pomegranate juice was significantly greater than that of cranberry juice; all products tested had higher TP values than hot cocoa mix (57.6 ± 4.9 mg/serving). Finally, the total flavanol content (Figure 2C) of dark chocolate (535.6 ± mg/serving) was significantly greater than cocoa beverage (400 ± 39.5 mg/serving) on a per serving basis and both dark chocolate and cocoa beverage had significantly greater total flavanol content than hot cocoa mix, acai, blueberry, cranberry, and pomegranate juice.
To limit sampling error with each analysis method, each brand of fruit powder and product was prepared and analyzed in triplicate. There was excellent agreement in ORAC, TP, and TF values within replicates of all brands tested. The largest coefficient of variation in ORAC was 0.095 (data not shown) for replicated tests of cocoa powder. The largest coefficient of variation in TP content was 0.085 (data not shown) for replicated tests of blueberry powder. The largest coefficient of variation in TF content was 0.088 (data not shown) for replicated tests of pomegranate powder. In contrast to the lack of methodological variability, there were significant differences in ORAC, TP, and TF values between brands of some fruit powders and, in particular, fruit products. As an example, statistically significant differences in ORAC, TP, and TF between brands of acai juice are demonstrated in Figure 3A, B and 3C.
The results of the current study demonstrate that cocoa powder has equivalent or significantly higher in vitro antioxidant activity, as measured by ORAC values, compared to the tested fruit powders. Similarly, the TP content of cocoa powder was equivalent to that of the fruit powders and its TF content was significantly higher than that of all the fruit powders tested. In addition, on a per serving basis, dark chocolate had a significantly higher ORAC value and TP content than all of the fruit juices other than pomegranate juice. The ORAC value and TP content reported for dark chocolate in the current study are consistent with previously published results . These results are also in keeping with a prior study which demonstrated greater ORAC values and TP content in pomegranate juice compared to the other fruit juices examined in the current study . Moreover, dark chocolate and water-based beverages made with natural cocoa had greater TF content than the tested fruit juices. In contrast, hot cocoa mix had significantly lower ORAC and TP values than all of the fruit juices.
It is important to note that the cocoa powders, cocoa beverages, and dark chocolates used in this study all contained natural (or non-alkalized) cocoa. In contrast, the hot cocoa mixes were made with alkalized or so called dutched, cocoa. Alkalinization is used to mellow the flavor of cocoa , however the process has been shown to destroy polyphenolic compounds  and is likely responsible for the significant differences in ORAC, TP, and TC values observed between hot cocoa mix and the other cocoa products. The extent of polyphenol destruction is proportional to the degree of alkalization and change in the water extractable pH of the resulting powder . Therefore, consumers should be aware that antioxidant capacity and polyphenol content may be severely diminished in alkalized cocoa powder and products made with alkalized cocoa.
While all of the fruit powders and fruit juices analyzed in this study have been previously referred to as Super Fruits in the popular media, the results of this study clearly demonstrate that not all brands of powders or juices from any particular fruit have the same antioxidant capacity or chemical composition. Current FDA regulations do not require that antioxidant capacity and/or polyphenol content be provided on food labels. Inclusion of this information, as has been suggested previously , could assist consumers in differentiating between brands and in making healthier food choices.
In summary, natural cocoa powder and dark chocolate have significantly greater TF values than the other fruit powders and juices tested, respectively. The high concentration of flavanols, as well as other flavonoid compounds not tested in this study, contributes directly to the observed TP and ORAC values of natural cocoa and dark chocolate. Cocoa powder thus provides nutritive value beyond that derived from its macronutrient composition. Based on this criterion, and borrowing terminology from popular media, cacao seeds should be considered a "Super Fruit" and products derived from cacao seed extracts, such as natural cocoa powder and dark chocolate, as "Super Foods". In contrast, products made with alkalized cocoa have relatively low ORAC, TP and TF values. It is important to note that ORAC, TP and TF values varied significantly between some brands of fruit powders and fruit juices. Therefore, consumers should be aware that brands of cocoa and fruit powders and products may differ substantially in their nutritive value.
Sample Collection and Preparation
Materials selected for this study included commercially available fruit powders [acai, blueberry, cranberry, pomegranate], natural (non-alkalized) cocoa, 100% non blended fruit juices [acai, blueberry, cranberry, pomegranate], natural cocoa beverage, solid dark chocolate (60-63% cacao), and hot cocoa mix. All powders were obtained via food ingredient vendors. All juices, solid dark chocolate, and hot cocoa mix were obtained at retail and analyzed in the form sold to consumers, ie. hot cocoa mixes were not combined with milk or water prior to analysis. Cocoa beverage was produced by combining 240 ml water, 25 g sugar, 1 g salt, and 12 g of natural cocoa powder and was designed to have a composition similar to that of the other fruit juices. One cup (240 ml) was considered a typical single serving of fruit juice or cocoa beverage, 40 g was considered a typical single serving of dark chocolate, and 28 g was considered a typical single serving of hot cocoa mix. Three brands were selected per fruit powder and fruit product. Each brand was analyzed for ORAC, TP, and TF in triplicate.
Antioxidant Capacity Analysis
Sample ORAC values were quantified by measuring the fluorescence of fluorescein in the presence of 2,2'-azobis(2-amidinopropane) dihydrochloride (AAPH) [11, 12]. Quantitation was based on a trolox (6-hydroxy,2,5,7,8-tetramethylchroman-2-carboxylic acid) standard calibration curve, and results are reported as μm trolox equivalents per gram of sample for fruit powders and μm trolox equivalents per serving for fruit products.
Total Polyphenol Assay
Sample total polyphenol content was determined colorimetrically at 755 nm using Folin-Ciocalteu reagent as described by Singleton et al. . Quantitation was based on a gallic acid standard calibration curve. Total polyphenols are reported as gallic acid equivalents per gram of sample for fruit powders and gallic acid equivalents per serving for fruit products.
Total Flavanol Assay
Sample total flavanol content was determined colorimetrically at 640 nm using 4-dimethylaminocinnamaldehyde (DMAC) as described by Payne et al. . Quantitation was based on a procyanidin B-2 standard calibration curve, and results are reported as mg/g of total flavanols per gram of sample for fruit powders and mg per serving for fruit products.
Fruit powders and products were compared using a one-way ANOVA with brand or type of fruit powder or product as the independent variable and ORAC, TP, and TF as dependent variables. The least square mean for each type of fruit powder or product was calculated from the mean value of the three brands used. Differences between brands or types of fruit powders or products were identified by a post hoc analysis conducted using Fisher's LSD. Analyses were conducted using The Statgraphics Centurion software purchased from Manugistics, Inc., Rockville, MD, 20852, USA.
Gross PM: Superfruits:(Top 20 Fruits Packed with Nutrients and Phytochemicals, Best Ways to Eat Fruits for Maximum Nutrition, and 75 Simple and Delicious Recipes for Overall Wellness). 2009, New York: McGraw-Hill
Cuatrecasas J: Cacao and its allies: a taxonomic revision of the genus Theobroma. Contributions from the United States National Herbarium. 1964, 35: 379-614.
Beckett ST: Industrial chocolate manufacture and use. 1988, Glasgow: Blackie
Corti R, Flammer AJ, Hollenberg NK, Luscher TF: Cocoa and Cardiovascular Health. Circulation. 2009, 119: 1433-1441. 10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.108.827022.
Keen CL, Holt RR, Oteiza PI, Fraga CG, Schmitz HH: Cocoa antioxidants and cardiovascular health. Am J Clin Nutr. 2005, 81: 298S-303S.
Selmi C, Cocchi CA, Lanfredini M, Keen CL, Gershwin ME: Chocolate at heart: The anti-inflammatory impact of cocoa flavanols. Mol Nutr Food Res. 2008, 52: 1340-8. 10.1002/mnfr.200700435.
Miller KB, Hurst WJ, Flannigan N, Ou B, Lee CY, Smith N, Stuart DA: Survey of commercially available chocolate- and cocoa-containing products in the United States. 2. Comparison of flavan-3-ol content with nonfat cocoa solids, total polyphenols, and percent cacao. J Agric Food Chem. 2009, 57: 9169-9180. 10.1021/jf901821x.
Seeram NP, Aviram M, Zhang Y, Henning SM, Feng L, Dreher M, Heber D: Comparison of antioxidant potency of commonly consumed polyphenol-rich beverages in the United States. J Agric Food Chem. 2008, 56: 1415-1422. 10.1021/jf073035s.
Minifie BW: Cocoa Processes. Chocolate, Cocoa, and Confectionery: Science and Technology. 1989, New York: Chapman & Hall, 35-84.
Miller KB, Hurst WJ, Payne MJ, Stuart DA, Apgar J, Sweigart DS, Ou B: Impact of alkalization on the antioxidant and flavanol content of commercial cocoa powders. J Agric Food Chem. 2008, 56: 8527-8533. 10.1021/jf801670p.
Huang D, Ou B, Hampsch-Woodill M, Flanagan JA, Deemer EK: Development and validation of oxygen radical absorbance capacity assay for lipophilic antioxidants using randomly methylated beta-cyclodextrin as the solubility enhancer. J Agric Food Chem. 2002, 50: 1815-1821. 10.1021/jf0113732.
Ou B, Hampsch-Woodill M, Prior RL: Development and validation of an improved oxygen radical absorbance capacity assay using fluorescein as the fluorescent probe. J Agric Food Chem. 2001, 49: 4619-4626. 10.1021/jf010586o.
Singleton VL, Rossi JA: Colorimetry of total phenolics with phosphomolybdic-phosphotungstic acid reagents. Am J Enol Vitic. 1965, 16: 144-158.
Payne MJ, Hurst WJ, Stuart DA, Ou B, Fan E, Ji H, Kou Y: Determination of Total Procyanidins in Selected Chocolate and Confectionery Products Using DMAC. Journal of AOAC International. 2010, 93: 89-96.
Acknowledgements and funding
The authors would like to express sincere appreciation to Austin Snyder and Allison Dilzer for technical assistance and Dr. David Stuart for suggestions and critical reading of the manuscript. This work was funded by The Hershey Company (Hershey, PA).
SJC is a paid contractor for The Hershey Company. AGP, WJH, MJP, JM, LH, and DLM are employees of The Hershey Company.
AGP, JM, and DLM conceived and designed the study. WJH and MJP carried out the chemical assays. SJC performed the data analysis and drafted the manuscript. LH performed the statistical analysis. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.